Parents rarely ask which math app is best. They ask which one is worth money, and these three answer that question in completely different ways. Prodigy gives all of its math away free and sells game extras. SplashLearn sells polished game-based lessons for the youngest learners, but parents cannot even see the price until signup.
IXL sells structured, school-aligned practice with the deepest parent reports of the three, and gives away only ten free questions a day. We checked every price and free-tier claim in this comparison on the vendors’ own pages in October 2026.
Quick answer: Short on time? Start with Prodigy, because its math lessons are completely free and a membership only buys pets, gear and parent extras. SplashLearn is the strongest pick for Pre-K to Grade 5 game-based lessons, but parents get a 7-day trial, not a free plan, and the price appears during signup.
IXL is the pick for structured, school-aligned practice and reports you can act on, at $79 a year for one child, math only. None of the three is best for every family, so match the app to your child in the verdicts below.
Prodigy vs SplashLearn vs IXL at a Glance
The table is the whole argument on one screen. Read the free tier row first, because it explains the other eleven: one of these companies sells content, one sells extras around free content, and one sells lessons bundled with live classes.
| Factor | Prodigy | SplashLearn | IXL |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Fantasy game world powered by math questions | Game-based lessons, live classes and books | Structured skill practice with a SmartScore |
| Grades | 1 to 8 (Math), 1 to 6 (English) | Pre-K to Grade 5 | PreK to 12 |
| Subjects | Math, Science content on Plus and Ultra, English on Ultra | Math and Reading, live classes, books on the Books option | Math, Language Arts, Science, Social Studies, Spanish |
| Free tier | All educational questions free forever | No free plan for parents. 7-day trial, card required, auto-charges | 10 free questions per subject per day, progress not saved |
| Parent price, 1 child, 1 year | Core $58.95 (Math only), Plus $88.95, Ultra $118.95. Or $0 and skip membership | Plans start at $7.49 a month billed annually, per the vendor’s homepage FAQ. Full prices shown during signup. Family Annual covers up to 3 children | Math only $79 a year. Combo $129 a year. Core Subjects $159 a year |
| Monthly billing | $9.95 Core, $14.95 Plus, $19.95 Ultra | Monthly plan offered, price shown at signup | $9.95 to $19.95 a month by package |
| What paying unlocks | Pets, gear, Epics, extra Magicoin, Goals, Cheers, printable Practice Sheets | The full program: curriculum, live classes, worksheets, game zone, books option | Unlimited practice, saved progress, Analytics, diagnostic, awards and certificates |
| Extra children | Per-child memberships. Family Bundle $399 a year for up to 3 children | Family Annual covers up to 3 children under one plan | Add $4 a month or $40 a year per extra child |
| Parent reports | Free Parent Portal, Monthly Report Card email, Curriculum Progress Report. Goals and Practice Sheets for members | Parent dashboard and parent app with real-time progress insights | IXL Analytics, detailed skill reports, weekly progress emails (members) |
| Offline use | Online game world | App can be used without internet and syncs later | No, needs an internet connection |
| Ads and pressure on kids | No third-party ads. Free players see member-only pets and gear | Ad-free | No ads, no game store |
| Trial or guarantee | No trial needed, the lessons are free | 7-day free trial, once per user, card up front | No family trial. 30-day money-back guarantee on annual plans |
What Is Actually Free (and What Is Not)

Prodigy: everything educational is free. Prodigy’s own FAQ states it plainly: the in-game educational questions in Prodigy Math and Prodigy English are free.
There is no trial clock and no question cap, and a free parent account still includes the Parent Portal, a Monthly Report Card email, and a Curriculum Progress Report.
Membership money buys things around the math, never the math itself.
SplashLearn: a trial, not a free plan. For parents there is no free-forever tier. SplashLearn’s support pages describe a 7-day free trial that applies once per user, asks for payment details up front, and charges automatically when the trial ends unless you cancel first.
The genuinely free route is a teacher account: SplashLearn is free for teachers and schools, and students keep home access through their class, so ask your child’s teacher before paying anything.
IXL: ten questions a day. IXL’s own help center says that without a membership, a student can practice ten free questions in each subject per day, and progress is not saved. That is a taster, not a tier. One warning, because it circulates everywhere: pages claiming IXL gives 30 free questions a day are wrong. IXL’s help center says ten.
Prodigy: A Game World Where the Math Is Free
Prodigy Math wraps curriculum questions for grades 1 to 8 inside a fantasy game world of battles and quests, with more than 1,500 skills aligned to state standards. A placement test runs on first play, and the game adapts to your child’s answers from there. Prodigy English covers grades 1 to 6 on the same model.
The membership tiers, from Prodigy’s own pricing page, are Core at $58.95 a year (one game, math, progress tracking and goal setting), Plus at $88.95 a year (adds Science content, Mythical Epics, more pets and gear), and Ultra at $118.95 a year (adds Prodigy English).
Monthly billing runs $9.95, $14.95 and $19.95 a month by tier, and annual plans save about half. What the money buys is motivation and extras: pets, gear, mounts, extra Magicoin, plus parent Goals, Cheers and printable Practice Sheets.
The honest caution is built into that list. A membership buys motivation, not math, because the math is already free. A child can also spend a good share of a session exploring and battling between questions, so use the free Parent Portal reports to confirm how much math actually happened before you pay for extras.
SplashLearn: Game-Based Lessons for the Youngest Learners
SplashLearn is a game-based learning program for Pre-K through Grade 5, describing 8,000+ activities aligned to Common Core across Math and Reading.
Short curriculum games sit inside personalized learning paths, and the membership adds live Math and Reading classes (Monday to Thursday for the US and Canada), printable worksheets, and a Game Zone, with an interactive book library on the Books option.
It is ad-free, and its app can be used without an internet connection and syncs progress later, the only one of the three that travels well.
Parents choose between two membership options, “Math & English” and “Math & English + Books,” billed monthly or annually, and the Family Annual plan covers up to 3 children under one plan. Now the problem, stated plainly: SplashLearn barely publishes its prices.
The only public figure is a starting price in its own homepage FAQ, plans starting at $7.49 a month when billed annually, while the full price list sits on the logged-in subscription page, and website and in-app prices may differ.
So the honest answer to “what does SplashLearn cost?” is a starting price up front and the real total during signup, after the trial clock is already being set up. Judge it inside the trial if you try it, and set a cancel reminder for day 6.
Two more cautions. Content stops at Grade 5, so a family with an older child will outgrow it. And the trial needs a card before it starts, which is exactly the detail parents most often miss.
IXL: Structured Practice With Reports Parents Can Act On
IXL is not a game world and does not pretend to be. It is structured skill practice for PreK to 12 across Math, Language Arts, Science, Social Studies and Spanish.
Students work through skill plans, one exact skill at a time, which makes IXL the easiest of the three for targeting something specific like place value or a weak set of fact families.
Two tools carry the product: the SmartScore, which measures how fully a skill is mastered rather than a simple percentage, and the Real-Time Diagnostic, which pinpoints each child’s level and recommends the exact skills to work on next.
Family pricing from IXL’s membership page: Single Subject is $9.95 a month or $79 a year per child, the Combo of Math and Language Arts is $129 a year, and Core Subjects (Math, Language Arts, Science, Social Studies) is $159 a year.
Each additional child adds just $4 a month or $40 a year, the cheapest sibling rate of the three. Paying unlocks unlimited practice, saved progress, IXL Analytics with detailed per-skill reports, weekly emailed progress reports, the diagnostic, and awards and certificates. There is no family free trial, and IXL offers a 30-day money-back guarantee on annual plans.
The caution is the format itself. This is honest drill, and some children find it repetitive. The children who thrive on IXL are the ones who like watching a SmartScore climb toward 100.
What Each App Costs a Real Family
One child, math only, one year: Prodigy costs $0 free, or $58.95 with a Core membership. IXL costs $79. SplashLearn says plans start at $7.49 a month billed annually, with the full price shown at signup, so treat any exact total a review site quotes as unverified.
Two children, math only, one year: IXL costs $79 plus $40 for the second child, $119 total. Prodigy costs $0 free, or two Core memberships at $58.95 each, $117.90, since standard memberships attach to one child. SplashLearn’s Family Annual covers both children under one plan, at the price shown in signup.
Three children, math only, one year: IXL costs $79 plus $40 plus $40, $159 total. SplashLearn’s Family Annual still covers all three under the one plan.
Prodigy’s Family Bundle, priced on the vendor’s own blog at $399 a year, covers up to 3 children and adds homeschool tools like a parent dashboard with assignments, making it the most expensive route here unless you specifically want those tools.
Parent Reports: What You Can Actually See

Prodigy gives its reports away. The free Parent Portal shows progress as your child plays, a Monthly Report Card email breaks progress down skill by skill, and a Curriculum Progress Report shows where your child stands against the curriculum. Members add Goals and Cheers for steering and encouragement, plus printable Practice Sheets.
SplashLearn gives parents a dashboard and a parent app with real-time progress tracking and insights, in the vendor’s own listing words. It is the most glanceable of the three, designed for a quick check rather than a deep dive.
IXL goes deepest, and it is members-only.
IXL Analytics reports progress skill by skill, the Real-Time Diagnostic turns answers into a named level and a list of next skills, and weekly progress emails keep the picture current without logging in.
If you are the parent who reads reports and adjusts the week’s practice, this is the reporting you are paying for.
Which One Should Your Family Pay For?

The game-motivated child
Prodigy. Start free, because the math costs nothing. Pay for Core only if the pets and gear are what keep your child coming back, and use the free Parent Portal to confirm real math is happening between the battles.
The structured-practice child
IXL. Skill plans, a diagnostic that finds gaps, and reports a parent can act on. It fits a child who tolerates or enjoys drill, and a parent who wants practice aligned to what school is teaching.
The budget family
Prodigy’s free tier first, at $0. If you need reports and structure more than a game, IXL Single Subject at $79 a year is the cheapest paid route with real analytics.
Keep practice going between apps with our free multiplication chart, which never asks for a membership. SplashLearn only makes the budget list if the trial proves your child loves it, with a cancel reminder set before day 7.
The multi-kid family
IXL usually wins on math-only value, because each extra child is $40 a year, so three children cost $159 a year for math.
SplashLearn’s Family Annual covering up to 3 children can compete, but its price only appears at signup, so compare it live.
Prodigy’s $399 Family Bundle is the most expensive route and makes sense only if you want its homeschool tools too.
The school-aligned practice family
IXL, for PreK to 12 standards coverage and the Real-Time Diagnostic. SplashLearn is the classroom mirror for Pre-K to Grade 5, and it is free in many classrooms through teacher accounts, so ask your child’s teacher before paying. Prodigy works best as the fun supplement on top, not as the alignment tool.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Prodigy Math really free?
Yes. Prodigy’s own FAQ states that the in-game educational questions in Prodigy Math and Prodigy English are free. Memberships buy game extras like pets and gear, plus parent extras like Goals and printable Practice Sheets. They do not unlock lessons.
Is IXL free for homeschoolers?
Only as a taster. IXL’s help center says anyone can practice ten free questions in each subject per day, but progress is not saved and there are no reports. Unlimited practice, saved progress and Analytics need a family membership, which starts at $79 a year for one subject for one child.
Does SplashLearn have a free version for parents?
No. Parents get a 7-day free trial, and SplashLearn’s support pages say payment details are required up front and the plan charges automatically when the trial ends unless you cancel. The free route is a teacher account: SplashLearn is free for teachers and classrooms, and students can use it at home through their class.
Which app is best for a child who hates worksheets?
Prodigy, because practice is hidden inside a game world of battles and quests, and it costs nothing to test. SplashLearn is the better game-style pick for Pre-K to Grade 5 children who want short lessons and live classes instead of an open game world.
Which of the three works without internet?
SplashLearn. Its app can be used without an internet connection and syncs progress when you reconnect, per SplashLearn’s program materials. Prodigy is an online game world and IXL loads its questions online, so both need a connection. For travel days, our free worksheet generator prints practice that works anywhere.
Can siblings share one membership?
It depends on the app. IXL charges per child but adds each extra child for $40 a year. SplashLearn’s Family Annual plan covers up to 3 children under one plan. Prodigy memberships are per child, and its Family Bundle covers up to 3 children at $399 a year.
Whichever app you choose, pair screen practice with paper practice: screens quiz, paper proves. Our free math tools page holds a multiplication chart, step-by-step calculators and a worksheet generator that stay free in the way Prodigy’s math is free, with no trial clock attached.
Every topic clicks faster with practice. Our Resource Library has free lesson packs with slides, printable worksheets and full answer keys, ready to download and teach.
Members unlock every lesson in the library, including the full Fractions, Multiplication, Place Value, Addition & Subtraction, Time & Money and Geometry & Shapes units. See the full library



