Watch a student stare at 46 + 28 on a worksheet and freeze. The symbols are clear enough, but they point to nothing the child has ever touched.
Now hand that same student four ten-rods and six unit cubes, then two more ten-rods and eight more cubes, and ask what happens when the loose cubes pile past ten. The freeze melts — that is the CRA model at work.
What Does CRA Stand For in Math?
CRA stands for Concrete, Representational, Abstract: the three stages of the CRA model, a path for teaching any math concept. In the concrete stage, students handle physical objects like base-ten blocks or counters. In the representational stage, they draw or study pictures of those objects. In the abstract stage, they work with numbers and symbols alone.
The idea traces back to psychologist Jerome Bruner, who argued in the 1960s that learners move from hands-on action to images to symbols when they build new knowledge. The CRA model turns that insight into a daily teaching habit, a sequence you run through whenever a concept is new.
Why Does the Order Matter in the CRA Model?
Order matters because each stage gives meaning to the next one. The concrete stage builds a memory in the hands: ten loose cubes trade for one ten-rod, because the student performed the trade.
The picture stage turns that memory into something the mind can replay without the blocks on the desk. By the time symbols arrive, the equation 46 + 28 = 74 is shorthand for a story the student has already lived.
Reverse the order and the damage is predictable. A student who memorizes “carry the one” without ever trading blocks can follow the steps and still have no idea what the little 1 means. The procedure works on Tuesday’s homework and collapses on Friday’s word problem, because symbols with no meaning behind them are just decoration.
What Happens in the Concrete Stage of the CRA Model?
The concrete stage is gloriously physical. Students pick up, move, group, and trade real objects while narrating what they are doing. For 24 + 35, they build 24 with two ten-rods and four cubes, build 35 with three ten-rods and five cubes, push the groups together, and trade ten loose cubes for one more rod.
Two details make or break this stage. First, connect the symbols to the blocks from the first day, saying “we write 24 for these two rods and four cubes” so the abstract is never a stranger. Second, give students enough time here. Rushing past the blocks to get to the “real math” is the most common way the CRA model fails.
How Do Pictures Bridge the Gap?
The representational stage asks students to draw what they just built. After trading blocks for 24 + 35, they sketch quick rectangles for rods and dots for cubes, circle ten dots, and draw an arrow showing the trade.
The drawing does not need to be pretty. It needs to be accurate enough that the student can read the math back out of it.
This stage is the bridge, and bridges cannot be skipped. A drawing is portable in a way blocks are not: it fits in a notebook and can be replayed in the mind during a test. It is also the stage where students start to generalize. When they have drawn the ten-for-one trade five times, they begin to expect it.
When Is a Student Ready for Symbols?
A student is ready for the abstract stage when they can explain the symbols using the earlier stages. Show them 24 + 35 = 74 stacked vertically and ask what the small 1 above the tens column means.
If they can say “that is the ten we made from the loose ones, like when we traded the cubes,” they are ready.
Readiness is not a single promotion day for the whole class. Some students will live in symbols after two days, while others need the blocks for two weeks, and both timelines are normal. Keep the manipulatives available even after most of the class has moved on.
Common Mistake: Skipping the picture stage in the CRA model and jumping straight from blocks to symbols. The concrete experience fades from memory, the symbols arrive with nothing to attach to, and students end up memorizing steps they cannot explain. Always let the drawings do their bridging work.
What Does Skipping a Stage Cost?
A second grader learns 46 minus 28 by following steps: cross out the 4, make it 3, put a 1 next to the 6. She gets the right answer and everyone moves on. Two months later, faced with 406 minus 28, she applies the same steps and gets 222. She has no idea it is wrong, because she never understood what the steps meant. This is the price of skipping the concrete stage: procedures without meaning, brittle and ready to break.
The same problem taught through CRA looks different. First, the student builds 46 with base-ten blocks and physically trades a ten-rod for ten ones. She feels the trade. Then she sketches what she did, drawing the rods and ones. Only then does she write the numbers, and each digit in her written work points to something her hands have held. When she meets 406 minus 28, her hands remember what to do, and the steps make sense.
Teachers sometimes worry that manipulatives slow students down. The opposite is true over time. Students who build the concept concretely need less reteaching, make fewer errors, and solve novel problems faster. The concrete stage is not a delay. It is a shortcut disguised as a scenic route.
How Do You Know When to Move From One Stage to the Next?
Watch the hands. In the concrete stage, students who are ready to move on start predicting before they finish building. They place the blocks and say “I know this will be 18” halfway through. That prediction is the signal: the concept is forming, and the picture stage will let them test it faster than blocks allow.
In the pictorial stage, readiness looks like impatience with drawing. A student sketches three quick rectangles instead of detailed blocks, or starts writing numbers beside the pictures without being asked. They are telling you the picture has done its job and the symbols are calling. Follow their lead, but keep the pictures available. Moving forward does not mean burning the bridge.
The most common mistake is moving the whole class at once. In any group, some students will be ready for symbols while others still need the blocks. Let them move at different speeds. A student drawing pictures in May is not behind. They are building the understanding that will make them fast in September. The stages are not a race with one finish line.
Try It: Run One Lesson Through All Three Stages

Step 1: Build 46 – 28 with blocks. Each pair builds 46 with base-ten blocks and tries to take away 28. They will hit the wall: six cubes cannot cover eight.
Let the struggle sit for a minute, then ask what trade would solve it. When someone trades one rod for ten cubes, they finish with one rod and eight cubes: 18.
Step 2: Sketch exactly what happened. On paper, students draw their starting 46 as rods and dots, circle the rod they broke apart, and cross out the 28 they removed. Walk around and check that the sketches match the block moves.
Step 3: Write the symbols last. Now stack 46 over 28 on the board. Ask the class where each mark comes from. The crossed-out 4 becomes a 3 because we broke one rod. The 6 becomes 16 because of the ten new cubes. Every digit now points back to something fingers have touched.
Step 4: Name the pattern. Close by asking what the three passes had in common. Students will say the trading happened every time, just in different forms. That sentence, in their own words, is the concept.
Quick Practice
Question: A student solves 53 – 27 correctly with base-ten blocks but writes the stacked subtraction wrong, recording the borrowed ten as a 10 in the ones column. Which stage of the CRA model needs more work?
Answer: The representational stage. The student understands the trade physically but cannot yet map it onto a drawing or the written form. Have them sketch the trade step by step and label each part of the sketch with the matching digit.
Related Terms
- Place Value: the concept CRA was practically invented to teach.
- Base Ten: the system of tens that blocks make visible.
- Regrouping: the trading move students feel first with blocks, then write with symbols.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long should students stay in the concrete stage?
Until they can explain what they are doing without prompting. Watch for students narrating the math in their own words. That narration is the signal that the idea is taking root.
Can older students still benefit from the CRA model?
Absolutely. The CRA model works for any new concept at any age, including fractions and decimals. Older students move through the stages faster, but skipping them still produces hollow procedural knowledge.
Do students have to master each stage before moving on?
Not perfectly, and the stages can overlap. A student might draw while still checking with blocks. The point of the CRA model is the sequence of experiences, not a locked gate between stages.
What manipulatives work best for the concrete stage?
The ones that match the math: base-ten blocks for place value, fraction tiles for fractions, two-color counters for integers. The best manipulative is the one whose structure mirrors the concept.
Is the representational stage just drawing pictures?
It is drawing with a purpose. The sketches stand in for the objects and must show the mathematical structure accurately. A quick, correct sketch beats a beautiful, vague one every time.
Do older students still need the concrete stage?
Yes, whenever the concept is new. A fifth grader learning fraction division benefits from physical models just as much as a first grader learning addition. The stages apply to the newness of the idea, not the age of the child. Never assume a concept is “too easy” for manipulatives.
What if I do not have enough manipulatives for every student?
Pairs work fine, and so do drawings. The pictorial stage is powerful on its own when students draw with intention. You can also use everyday objects: buttons for counters, straws bundled for tens, paper strips for fractions. The math does not know whether the blocks came from a catalog.
How long should each stage last?
There is no fixed timetable. Some concepts need a day in each stage; others need two weeks concrete. Let student understanding set the pace, not the calendar. The only rule is the order: never symbols first, and never skip a stage entirely.
Every topic clicks faster with practice. Our Resource Library has free lesson packs with slides, printable worksheets and full answer keys, ready to download and teach.
Members unlock every lesson in the library, including the full Fractions, Multiplication, Place Value, Addition & Subtraction, Time & Money and Geometry & Shapes units. See the full library



