Teaching Textbooks vs CTCMath: Which Homeschool Math Program Fits Your Family?

Teaching Textbooks and CTCMath promise the same thing: a math program that teaches and grades for you, so math gets done even on the days you cannot teach it yourself. They differ in three ways that decide the choice. You pay per course with Teaching Textbooks and per membership with CTCMath.

Teaching Textbooks starts at grade 3, while CTCMath starts at Kindergarten. And a Teaching Textbooks enrollment locks to one level, while CTCMath lets a student work at any grade inside one membership. Every price and feature below was checked on the two vendors’ own websites in October 2026.

Quick answer: Cheapest for one child at list prices: Teaching Textbooks, under $84 a year for any single course against $257 for CTCMath. Best for several children at different levels: CTCMath, one family membership with every grade included.

Best safety nets for a struggling learner: Teaching Textbooks, with hints, read-aloud problems, a video solution for every problem, and a free phone tutor line. Best for filling gaps: CTCMath, with diagnostic tests and free movement between all grade levels.

Only one works offline: Teaching Textbooks, for up to 6 lessons at a time in its app.

Teaching Textbooks vs CTCMath at a Glance

Here is the whole comparison on one screen. The sections after the table explain what each row means for a real family.

FeatureTeaching TextbooksCTCMath
Price$48.95 (Math 3 to 5), $63.95 (Math 6 to 7), $79.95 (Pre-Algebra, Algebra 1, Geometry), $83.95 (Algebra 2, Pre-Calculus) per student, per course, per year. Large Family Plan $239.95 for 4 to 8 students$257 per year for one student, $397 per year for a family plan (monthly options $39.99 and $59.99). Frequent homeschool discounts
Grades coveredMath 3 to Pre-Calculus (starts at grade 3)Kindergarten to grade 12, through Calculus, all levels in one membership
FormatApp-based course, one level at a time, followed in order, eBook built inBrowser-based lesson library, any lesson in any order, printable worksheets optional
Lesson lengthA full video lecture with every lesson, 100+ hours of teaching per courseShort video tutorials, about 4 to 9 minutes each
Auto-gradingYes, every problem graded instantly, with a step-by-step video solution for every problemYes for interactive questions and most worksheets. A few upper-level lessons are self-graded against worked solutions
Placement testsFree placement test for every levelDiagnostic test for every topic, grades K to 8, with a report of lessons to review
Parent reportsParent Portal gradebook for every student, daily progress emailDetailed reports online anytime, weekly progress report by email
Offline useYes, up to 6 lessons at a time in the appNo, lessons stream online in the browser
Free trialFirst 15 lessons of any level, no card taken, no expiry dateFree trial from the CTCMath homepage
Money-back guarantee30 days from the course start date12-month money-back guarantee, stated in CTCMath’s own promotional pages
Best forOne or two children, parents who want teaching and grading fully handled, offline useSeveral children, gap-filling across levels, Kindergarten starters, short lessons

How Each Program Teaches

A video lesson diagram with a play button, a checklist and a timer, showing how both programs teach math with short videos
Teaching Textbooks guides a full course in order. CTCMath opens a library of short lessons your child can visit in any order.

Teaching Textbooks is a complete guided course. Every lesson opens with a video lecture, and the student follows the course in order, one level at a time.

The approach is spiral: every assignment mixes new material with review of earlier concepts, so nothing gets forgotten quietly.

Problems can be read aloud, hints appear when a student needs one, a built-in scratchpad sits beside the work, and every single problem carries a full step-by-step audiovisual solution.

Behind the course sits a free tutor helpline by phone, and each course holds at least 100 hours of audiovisual teaching plus a 500 to 900 page eBook inside the app.

CTCMath is a lesson library. Every lesson is written and voiced by the same teacher, Pat Murray, in a short video tutorial of about 4 to 9 minutes, followed by interactive questions or an optional printable worksheet with worked solutions.

The approach is mastery: questions adapt in difficulty, and a student is expected to reach a mastery level on a lesson before moving on. Because every grade sits inside one membership, a parent can assign a lesson from any level, in any order, on any day.

The honest feel difference: Teaching Textbooks feels like a teacher-led course your child follows. CTCMath feels like a well-organized library that you direct. Neither feel is better in the abstract. It depends on whether your child needs a path or needs freedom.

What Each Program Costs

A calculator and a neat stack of five coins on a desk, for comparing what Teaching Textbooks and CTCMath cost each year
Per-course pricing against one yearly membership: the winner flips with family size and with CTCMath’s frequent discounts.

All prices below are list prices checked in October 2026. Teaching Textbooks charges per student, per course, for a 12-month enrollment: $48.95 for Math 3 to 5, $63.95 for Math 6 to 7, $79.95 for Pre-Algebra, Algebra 1 and Geometry, and $83.95 for Algebra 2 and Pre-Calculus.

There are no extra fees or in-app purchases. CTCMath charges $257 a year for one student or $397 a year for a family membership covering more than one student, with monthly options at $39.99 and $59.99.

What that means for real families, at list prices:

  • One 4th grader: Teaching Textbooks Math 4 costs $48.95 a year. CTCMath costs $257 a year.
  • Two children, grades 4 and 7: Teaching Textbooks costs $48.95 + $63.95 = $112.90 a year. CTCMath family membership costs $397 a year.
  • Four or more children: the Teaching Textbooks Large Family Discount Plan costs $239.95 a year for 4 to 8 students. CTCMath family membership costs $397 a year. Teaching Textbooks itself notes on its plan page that buying individual courses sometimes works out cheaper than the plan, so run your own numbers first.

One honest warning before the list prices settle anything: CTCMath discounts often.

Its homeschool promotions commonly land near half price through its own offers and the Homeschool Buyers Co-op, and at half price the CTCMath family plan drops to about $198.50, which undercuts the Teaching Textbooks family plan.

So for three or more children, the live offers on buying day decide the winner, not this table.

Refund terms differ as much as prices. Teaching Textbooks gives you 30 days from the course start date to opt out for a refund, plus a level exchange if the placement was wrong.

CTCMath’s own promotional pages state a 12-month money-back guarantee. That guarantee does not appear in CTCMath’s FAQ, so confirm the current wording on its purchase page before you rely on it.

Grading, Reports and Parent Time

Teaching Textbooks grades every problem the moment the answer is entered, and the grade waits.

Parents see every student’s grades in one printable gradebook inside the Parent Portal, get a daily email showing progress, and can edit or delete answers for a whole lesson or a single problem when a bad day needs a redo.

Day to day, it asks almost nothing of the parent.

CTCMath marks interactive questions and most worksheets automatically, and a parent can open detailed results online at any time or take the optional weekly progress report by email. Parents can also set tasks for each student and choose the pass mark a student must reach.

A small number of upper-level lessons, mainly in Algebra and Geometry, are self-graded by the student against the worked solutions, which is worth knowing before you buy for a teenager.

The trade is simple: Teaching Textbooks asks the least of you each day. CTCMath asks for a little more setup, assigning tasks and setting pass marks, in exchange for more control.

Placement, Catch-Up and Moving Levels

Teaching Textbooks manages placement risk with paperwork and policies. It offers a free printable placement test for every level, with scoring instructions, and the first 15 lessons of any level as a free trial that needs no payment details and never expires.

Trial work transfers into a paid course, though the company itself warns that the trial leans heavily on review from the previous level, so it is not a placement guide on its own. Each enrollment also includes 90 days of pause time.

The hard limit: one enrollment belongs to one student at one level. It cannot be shared between siblings, and if a student finishes early, the leftover time cannot roll into the next level. The 30-day exchange window is your protection if you choose wrong.

CTCMath manages the same risk with freedom. It offers a standard and a comprehensive diagnostic test for every topic in grades K to 8, and each finished test produces a report naming the lessons that may need review.

Inside the membership, a student can drop back two grade levels for one weak topic, such as place value, and jump ahead somewhere else, at no extra cost and with no new purchase. For a mid-year switcher, or a child whose skills are uneven, that freedom is CTCMath’s strongest argument.

Which One Fits Your Family?

A balance scale with a book on one side and a laptop on the other, sitting level, for choosing between Teaching Textbooks and CTCMath
Neither program wins for everyone. Your family type decides, and both free trials make the final test cheap.

On a tight budget: it depends on headcount. For one or two children, Teaching Textbooks at list price, and it is not close. For three or more, compare the live CTCMath homeschool discount against the Teaching Textbooks Large Family Plan on the day you buy, because CTCMath’s promotions can flip the result.

The hands-off parent: Teaching Textbooks. It teaches every lesson, grades every problem, emails you progress daily, and staffs a free tutor line for the questions you cannot answer. CTCMath runs independently too, but it expects you to assign tasks and set pass marks.

The struggling learner: genuinely split, so name the problem first. If your child gets stuck inside lessons, Teaching Textbooks wraps every problem in help: hints, read-aloud problems, instant grading, a video solution for every problem, and the tutor line.

If the problem is gaps from earlier years, CTCMath is stronger, because its diagnostics name the missing lessons and your child can drop back a level for one topic without a new purchase.

The large family: CTCMath for simplicity. One membership covers every child at every level, with no per-course decisions each August. If your family prefers the Teaching Textbooks teaching style, the $239.95 Large Family Plan keeps it in the argument.

Secular families: both are fine. Neither program builds religious teaching into its math lessons, so the choice can rest on teaching style and price alone.

Whichever way you lean, both programs offer a free trial. Run the same child through a week of each before you pay for either.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, Teaching Textbooks or CTCMath?

At list prices checked in October 2026, Teaching Textbooks charges per course, $48.95 to $83.95 per student per year, so one child costs under $84 a year, while CTCMath charges $257 a year for one student or $397 for a family plan. CTCMath runs frequent homeschool discounts, so check both sites before you decide.

Which program is better for a struggling learner?

Teaching Textbooks gives more help inside each problem, with hints, problems read aloud, instant grading, a step-by-step video solution for every problem, and a free phone tutor line. CTCMath helps in a different way, letting a student drop back to any earlier level at no extra cost and using diagnostic tests to name the exact lessons to review.

Can CTCMath replace a full curriculum?

Yes. CTCMath states that it is a full math curriculum for grades K to 12, not just a supplement, and one membership includes every grade and every lesson.

Does Teaching Textbooks run behind grade level?

Teaching Textbooks states that each course covers the standard topics for its level, with at least 100 hours of teaching per course. Because level names do not transfer cleanly between programs, the company offers free placement tests and advises using one instead of assuming your child’s grade number will match.

Are Teaching Textbooks and CTCMath secular or religious?

Neither program builds religious teaching into its math lessons, which is why both are used by secular and religious homeschool families alike.

How long are the lessons in each program?

CTCMath lessons are short video tutorials of about 4 to 9 minutes, followed by interactive questions or a worksheet. Teaching Textbooks pairs a full video lecture with each lesson, inside a course designed to be finished across a school year at roughly one lesson per weekday, within a 12-month enrollment that includes 3 months of pause time.

Both trials are free, so the cheapest research is an hour with each program and the same child. Watch where your child stalls, how much help they ask for, and whether you had to sit beside them.

That hour will tell you more than any comparison page, including this one. And whichever program you choose, our free math tools page gives your child extra practice on the side, with a multiplication chart, step-by-step calculators, and a worksheet generator, all free.

Try It With a Free Lesson

Every topic clicks faster with practice. Our Resource Library has free lesson packs with slides, printable worksheets and full answer keys, ready to download and teach.

Members unlock every lesson in the library, including the full Fractions, Multiplication, Place Value, Addition & Subtraction, Time & Money and Geometry & Shapes units. See the full library

Leave a Comment